Kate Moss at Topshop….what a joke

I queued patiently to buy some of the Celia magic, I tried to zone out the people standing around muttering “No idea who this woman is, but I know this stuff will sell on ebay”, I narrowly avoided being ripped to shreds as the rails were pushed out and all hell broke loose. I bought the pieces which had some manufacturing integrity (did anyone actually ever wear that botticelli print silk monstrosity?? so badly made I wanted to weep….) and put my years of hardened vintage shopping to good use as I walked around clutching the dress everyone was wetting themselves over and ignoring the black market-level dirty looks and whispers of ‘are you buying that?’

It was fun as a one-off. Something to tell the grandkids about, since I don’t have a Biba experience like that to share.

I didn’t bother second time around, the second collection was a poor relation and I don’t need the hassle. I’d rather spend my time and money getting an original.But at least she designed the prints and had some claim to the copied shapes of Ossie’s. The woman has talent.

Kate Moss in the original (left) and the Topshop copy (right)

Kate Moss at Topshop is a travesty. Normally such a non-event would barely register in the world of Ms. Peelpants. I couldn’t care less about Madonna at H&M, Lily Allen at New Look or even some of the least talented designers in the world getting deals with the same shops (naming no names, but I’ve heard some very interesting first-hand things about one of them lately and am suitably smug that I guessed they had no talent years ago). But Kate Moss at Topshop has affected me on a very personal level, and opened eyes to the true extent of the shallow money-grabbing at the heart of the fashion world these days.

I remember noting with amusement that Kate Moss had a vintage Bus Stop dress I also have. Much like the Ossie jacket she once wore, it’s always a nice little nod to the vintage community that vintage is still cool and it can do wonders for the image of what are, to most people’s minds, just someone’s old cast-offs. We know they’re not, but sometimes the challenge is to change other people’s perceptions. Kate Moss did the vintage community a lot of good in the past, but now she’s cheated on us.

For she has now ‘allowed’ (inverted commas to note that it is not her place to allow such a thing) Topshop to copy the aforementioned dress for her ‘collection’. A travesty so awful, on so many levels it’s taken me about a week to calm down enough to write this. They’ve copied the dress exactly, even down to getting the print copied and the detailing around the neck and on the sleeves. To add insult to injury, the dress in her closet had been hacked with what looks like nail scissors and is now a bum-skimming mini dress. I don’t know whether to laugh or cry when I see how badly out of proportion even the remake is. They’ve remade a ruined dress.

Lee Bender should sue Topshop. Her work has been copied stitch for stitch. It’s one thing to be inspired, Bender herself would have to admit that the dress was heavily inspired by dresses of the Forties, but there’s no room for the word inspiration here. This is duplication and it’s disgusting.

On a more personal level, one of my absolute favourite dresses has been ruined for me. This year everyone will think I’m wearing bleeding Kate Moss at Topshop. Next year, everyone will think I’m wearing two seasons old bleeding Kate Moss at Topshop. Two years time, perhaps the fashion world with its attention span of a gnat might have forgotten all about Kate Moss at Topshop (or perhaps Kate Moss herself, we can but hope).But my dress will still be tainted by the association and I resent the fact that I will always have to think carefully about whether to wear it or not. To sell it now would be to cash in. To sell next year, well no one will want the same problems I would have. But really, I don’t want to sell it. I bought it for me, and it fits me like it was stitched to my body.

Yours truly in the original dress

Advertisements

14 Comments on “Kate Moss at Topshop….what a joke”

  1. maya says:

    that dress is so incredible. it really does look perfect. i love your blog so much, want to swap links?

  2. Anonymous says:

    I'm sorry but I have to say that I am very appreciative of Ms. Moss' attempts at vintage-esque clothing. I live in Los Angeles, and 25 years ago vintage (really good vintage) was affordable. Now vintage is as expensive as buying a new over-priced designer frock. It's too expensive for something half-decent (you're lucky if there's no stains, rips or that terrible musky smell). All I have to say is, "Thank you, Kate!"

  3. Button Bunny says:

    I have to write and say that your dress looks so much better than the remake. I do think it's nice when people like the vintage look but when everyone has the same 'vintage' look it sort of spoils it…

  4. […] not just Topshop in the Noughties who enjoy ripping things off. Sometimes it seems like every minor boutique in London, New York and […]

  5. […] get angry enough when they copy beloved vintage pieces, never mind this… Share and share alike:Like this:LikeBe the first to like this […]

  6. […] were straight-up copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been seen in before – much to the irritation of people who owned the original and preferred to keep its cachet to themselves, as well as the pleasure of […]

  7. […] were straight-up copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been seen in before – much to the irritation of people who owned the original and preferred to keep its cachet to themselves, as well as the pleasure of […]

  8. […] copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been noticed in before – considerably to the irritation of men and women who owned the original and preferred to hold its cachet to themselves, as nicely as the pleasure of […]

  9. […] were straight-up copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been seen in before – much to the irritation of people who owned the original and preferred to keep its cachet to themselves, as well as the pleasure of […]

  10. […] were straight-up copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been seen in before – much to the irritation of people who owned the original and preferred to keep its cachet to themselves, as well as the pleasure of […]

  11. Pearl says:

    Remember the Moschino bag with the red heart? I had the original until Kate Moss was seen wearing it at Glasto and it was bastardised all over the high st. I sold it on ebay after that as I couldn’t bear it. BTW so cool that your old post is being bright to light again, it is a great post x

  12. […] were straight-up copy-and-stitch replicas of garments Moss had been seen in before – much to the irritation of people who owned the original and preferred to keep its cachet to themselves, as well as the pleasure of […]

  13. […] The gorgeous Emma from Get Some Vintage Appeal writes about her experience with the Kate Moss collection ripping off her own vintage Bus Stop dress in ‘Kate Moss at Topshop…What a Joke‘. […]

  14. […] pilfering of ‘inspirations’ which are frequently little more than duplications (see Kate Moss for Topshop… in fact, see Topshop. Full stop.) and the, albeit fair enough, archive collections by Laura […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s